Electroactive microbes can serve as living components in bioelectronic devices, where their unique ability to transfer electrons enables applications in sensing, energy conversion, and synthesis, but they remain challenging to engineer because the bioelectrochemical systems (BESs) used for characterization are low throughput. Here, we present a bioelectrochemical crossbar architecture screening platform (BiCASP) that uses stacked and orthogonally arrayed electrodes to enable individual sample selection for characterization in arrayed formats. This device reports on the current generated by electroactive bacteria on the minute timescale, decreasing the time for data acquisition by several orders of magnitude compared to conventional BESs. This device increases the throughput of screening engineered biological components in cells, identifying mutants of the membrane protein wire MtrA in Shewanella oneidensis that retain the ability to support extracellular electron transfer (EET). BiCASP may be integrated with bioelectronics that need directed evolution of electroactive proteins.